Market Trends · Updated 2026-10-16
The share of homeowners with seriously underwater mortgages is rising, and fewer homes are equity-rich than at any point in about five years, according to ATTOM data. When a home is worth less than the loan balance, that is precisely the situation where a short sale becomes relevant. If your equity has eroded, it is worth understanding what that means for your options.
What the equity data shows
About 41.1% of U.S. mortgaged homes were equity-rich in the second quarter of 2026, down from 44.6% at the end of 2025 and near a five-year low, according to ATTOM. At the same time, seriously underwater mortgages, where the loan balance is at least 25% above the home's value, rose to about 3.2% of mortgages, the highest since early 2022.
Nationwide, roughly 2% of mortgaged homes are in negative equity, up about 15% from a year earlier. The average mortgaged homeowner still holds meaningful equity, but the direction of the trend matters for homeowners who bought near the top or who have seen values cool.
What being underwater actually means
Being underwater means the home is worth less than what you owe against it. You still own the home and you can keep living in it as long as you make the payments. The problem only becomes urgent if you cannot afford the payments, because selling for full value will not pay off the loan.
That is the situation a short sale is built for: the lender agrees to accept a sale that does not fully cover the mortgage balance, rather than going through a costlier foreclosure.
How a lender decides on a short sale
The lender compares the net proceeds of a short sale with what it would recover through a foreclosure sale. When the short sale nets more, approval is a reasonable business decision. The smaller the gap between the sale price and the payoff, the simpler the file is to approve.
Your hardship also matters. Lenders look for a documented financial hardship, a property worth less than the debt, and a homeowner who genuinely cannot keep up the payments. Pay stubs, tax returns, bank statements, and a hardship letter make up the package the lender reviews.
If you think you might be underwater
The first step is not to assume a short sale is your only path. Get an honest read on your loan balance, your home's current value, and your payment situation. A Metro Atlanta broker experienced in distressed properties can help you see whether you have equity, whether a modification is realistic, or whether a short sale fits.
If you owe more than the home is worth and cannot continue payments, do not wait for the situation to resolve itself. The earlier you start, the more time the lender has to review your file before any foreclosure date.
The takeaway
Rising underwater mortgages mean more homeowners are in a position where a short sale can apply. If your equity has eroded and payments are a struggle, get a confidential review of your numbers before a deadline becomes critical.